‘GAYSROK’
SALT LAKE CITY - The state of Utah can't block a woman from using her license plate to tell the world "GAYSROK," a judge has ruled.
The state has no good reason to prevent Elizabeth Solomon from having that plate - which can be read "Gays are OK" or "Gays Rock" - or another one saying "GAYRYTS," according to Jane Phan, an administrative law judge with the Utah State Tax Commission.
"The narrow issue before us is whether a reasonable person would believe the terms "gays are OK" and "gay rights" are, themselves, offensive to good taste and decency. It is the conclusion of the commission that a reasonable person would not," Phan wrote.
The state can appeal the July 19 decision.
"We're discussing it, and we have 30 days to do that," Barry Conover, deputy director of the commission, which oversees Utah's Department of Motor Vehicles, said Wednesday.
The state has no good reason to prevent Elizabeth Solomon from having that plate - which can be read "Gays are OK" or "Gays Rock" - or another one saying "GAYRYTS," according to Jane Phan, an administrative law judge with the Utah State Tax Commission.
"The narrow issue before us is whether a reasonable person would believe the terms "gays are OK" and "gay rights" are, themselves, offensive to good taste and decency. It is the conclusion of the commission that a reasonable person would not," Phan wrote.
The state can appeal the July 19 decision.
"We're discussing it, and we have 30 days to do that," Barry Conover, deputy director of the commission, which oversees Utah's Department of Motor Vehicles, said Wednesday.
"It kind of opens up the door for all types of people who want to make a license plate a public forum, for every initiative," he said.
Dani Eyer, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Utah, which represented Solomon, countered: "The government can't pick and choose what subjects it likes and does not like."
Solomon, of Park City, on Wednesday said she considered the judge's decision as a victory for her daughter, who is gay, and for two gay male friends.
COMMENTARY
What is most amazing about this article is that any gays choose to stay in Utah.
This is another clear example of how the far right is pursuing an active, systemic campaign to destroy the gay community and send us back to the shadows.
"It kind of opens up the door for all types of people
who want
to make a license plate a public forum,
for every initiative,"
Oh, you mean just like the "PROLIFER" plate that I saw yesterday? Are license plates really that important of a medium? Personally, I think vanity plates are annoying and self-indulgent, but meaningful and impactful? No, I think not. And I don't think they do either...but it is one more place to try and stick it to us (forgive the pun, please).
"They" love to publicly claim that there is no intention to strip us of rights or treat us as second class citizens, just that they are simply preventing the implosion of our society - a claim which, in and of itself, is ridiculous. They insist we deserve the same as everyone else...just not marriage, equal protection, due process, and now license-plate design. What a collection of ass clowns!
"They" love to publicly claim that there is no intention to strip us of rights or treat us as second class citizens, just that they are simply preventing the implosion of our society - a claim which, in and of itself, is ridiculous. They insist we deserve the same as everyone else...just not marriage, equal protection, due process, and now license-plate design. What a collection of ass clowns!

1 Comments:
No joke! I can't believe the Utah government is suing to take away someone's 1st amendment rights in such an explicit and undeniable way. Hey, I hate rats, but I'm not going to sue for emotional distress if I see a plate that says RATSROK. And what about all of those bumperstickers and mud flaps with the naked lady silhouettes on them. Isn't that offensive to a reasonable person? The funny thing about the extreme right is what they do in private as opposed to in front of the media. A friend of mine worked for a bill collecting service that collected payments online--one of their clients was a porn site. His neighbor was a Church going Southern gentleman who apparently enjoyed purchasing porn featuring beastiality and all kinds of kinky stuff. Hypocrites.
16:44
Post a Comment
<< Home